Brown vs Pink Noise for Sleep: What Actually Helps (and When)

Brown vs Pink Noise for Sleep: What Actually Helps (and When)

Type

Sleeping Environment Guide

Date

Sep 2025

Written By

RestingLabs Team

Your bedroom probably is not silent. It hums, a fridge far away, a road in the distance, a neighbor’s TV through a wall, plus the occasional spike, a door slam, a truck, a snore burst right in your ear.

So the real question is not, “Is brown noise better than pink noise for sleep”. It is, “Which kind of sound makes your brain stop listening for trouble”. And if you have ADHD, tinnitus, or you share walls with loud humans, the answer might not be the same as for someone in a quiet house.


Guide • ~15 min read

text

What white, pink, and brown noise actually are

Let’s start with what your ears hear.

If you play all three back to back:

  • White noise sounds like a bright hiss

  • Pink noise sounds like a softer, deeper hiss, less harsh

  • Brown noise sounds like a distant waterfall, rumble, or heavy rain through walls

Under the hood:

  • White noise gives equal energy at all frequencies your ear can hear, so the high pitched part feels very present

  • Pink noise reduces energy as frequency increases, so highs are softer and lows are more prominent

  • Brown noise tilts even more toward low frequencies, so it feels deeper, heavier, more like a constant rumble

You do not need to do the math. The thing that matters for sleep is how your brain reacts when these sounds sit in the background for hours.

For some people, white noise is perfect, their brain likes the brighter hiss. For others, especially if they find high sounds annoying or are sensitive to “shshshsh” type noise, pink or brown noise feels calmer.

How colored noise might help sleep in the first place

Imagine your night as a graph.

  • The baseline is the hum in your room

  • The spikes are slamming doors, car horns, a partner’s snore, a dog bark

Your brain is surprisingly good at waking up for spikes, even if they are not very loud. It is less interested in smooth, predictable sound.

Pink, brown, and white noise all work on the same simple idea:

  1. Raise the baseline a little with a steady sound

  2. Make the small spikes less noticeable compared with that baseline

  3. Keep everything so predictable and boring that your brain tunes it out

The details differ:

  • Pink noise has a mix that matches the way your ears naturally hear everyday sounds

  • Brown noise leans into low frequencies that feel like distant traffic, planes far overhead, or surf

For light sleepers, that predictability is the appeal. For people with tinnitus, a gentle noise sometimes makes internal ringing less intrusive. For people with ADHD or anxiety, the constant sound can act like a blanket for the brain, something to “lean against” while falling asleep.

But which color does this best for you is not something a lab can fully answer. It is part physics, part psychology, part what your brain grew up around.

Pink noise, deep sleep, and memory consolidation

If you search “pink noise memory consolidation”, you will find an interesting pattern. In a small lab study, older adults listened to carefully timed pink noise pulses during deep sleep. Their slow wave sleep became more synchronized, and their next day memory scores improved a bit compared with a control night.

A couple of important caveats:

  • The pink noise was timed to their brain waves using EEG machines, not just played all night from a speaker

  • The sample sizes were small

  • This was a lab environment, not a noisy city apartment

So what can we take from that without over selling it:

  • Pink noise seems like a sound type that the sleeping brain can integrate well

  • It may have a modest ability to stabilize deep sleep under controlled conditions

  • That does not automatically mean “if you play pink noise from your phone, your memory will skyrocket”

For everyday use, pink noise for sleep is best seen as a gentle, lower pitched cousin of white noise, with some intriguing research behind it, not as a guaranteed cognitive enhancer.

Brown noise and ADHD sleep

Brown noise has become a social media mini star, especially in ADHD circles. If you type brown noise ADHD sleep into a search bar, you will see people saying it is the first thing that ever quieted their thoughts, for work or for bedtime.

What might be going on:

  • The deeper sound can feel more grounding than hissy white noise

  • Many people with ADHD report that a bit of background stimulation helps their brain focus or relax, silence feels louder than sound

  • Brown noise might be hitting that sweet spot for some, enough input to keep the “scanner” part of the brain busy, without being interesting enough to stay awake for

What we do not have yet:

  • Big, well controlled clinical trials showing that brown noise treats ADHD or reliably improves ADHD related sleep

  • Clear rules about which frequency profile works best for which subtype

So the safest way to frame it is:

  • Brown noise is a low risk experiment, not a treatment

  • It may help some people with ADHD or anxious, racing minds fall asleep or stay asleep more easily

  • It should always sit alongside sensible sleep routines and, if needed, proper ADHD care, not replace them

If you try brown noise for ADHD sleep, treat it like any other intervention, test it systematically for a couple of weeks and see if it earns its place.

Brown noise vs pink noise for sleep, how to actually choose

Instead of asking the internet to declare a winner, run your own mini study.

Here is a simple two week experiment you can do with a sound machine, a Loftie, or even a phone set up as a dedicated noise player.

Step 1, Set some constants

For all test nights:

  • Go to bed within the same 30 minute window

  • Keep your wake time fixed, even on weekends

  • Keep bedroom temperature and light roughly the same

  • Do not change your caffeine or alcohol timing halfway through

The idea is to change only the sound color, not your entire life.

Step 2, Test pink noise first

For nights 1 to 4:

  • Use pink noise at a low to moderate volume

  • Aim for “quiet room with texture” rather than “airplane cabin”

  • If you share a bed, agree on a volume together

Each morning, jot down:

  • How long it felt like it took you to fall asleep

  • How many times you remember waking up

  • How rested you felt out of 10

Step 3, Test brown noise

For nights 5 to 8:

  • Switch to brown noise, keep volume and routine the same

  • Same quick notes each morning

Step 4, Test no added noise

For nights 9 to 12:

  • No added noise, just your usual bedroom sounds

  • Earplugs are allowed if you use them normally, but keep them consistent

At the end, look for patterns:

  • Did pink noise, brown noise, or silence give you fewer wake ups

  • Which setting gave you better next day energy, even if it felt similar at night

  • Did any noise feel clearly annoying or claustrophobic

If one option clearly feels better, that is your answer. If they are all the same, noise might not be a big lever for your sleep, and that is useful to know too.

Devices, apps, and safe volume

You can try pink and brown noise with almost anything that makes sound, but a little setup goes a long way.

What to play them on

  • Dedicated sound machine with pink and brown noise options

  • Loftie or similar bedside clock, if you want to keep your phone out of the bedroom

  • Old phone or tablet repurposed as a noise player only, notifications off, screen dimmed or off

Try to avoid:

  • Leaving your main phone in bed as the player, the temptation to “just check one thing” is strong

  • Streams with sudden ads or jumps in volume

White noise safe decibel sleep levels, quick guide

You do not need blaring volume for masking to work.

  • Put the device across the room, not next to your head

  • Use a sound meter app if you can, at your pillow spot

  • Aim for around 30 to 45 dB A weighted at the pillow for adults

    • On the lower end if your home is already fairly quiet

    • On the higher end if you are masking city traffic or hallway noise

For babies and toddlers, keep machines well away from the crib and on lower settings. Pink or brown noise are not inherently safer or riskier than white noise, volume and distance are what matter.

Where white noise still fits

If you already sleep well with white noise, you do not have to switch. White noise is still:

  • Easy to find on almost every device

  • Effective at masking a wide range of environmental sounds

  • Totally fine for many people who are not sensitive to high pitched hiss

Pink and brown noise are worth trying if:

  • White noise feels too sharp or irritating

  • You have tinnitus that seems triggered by higher frequencies

  • You notice that deeper sounds, fans, distant traffic, help you more than hiss

In other words, white noise is the default, pink and brown noise are refinements.

Summary

Brown noise, pink noise, and white noise are all steady sounds, but with different “shapes”. Pink and brown noise tilt more energy toward lower frequencies, which many people find less sharp than classic white noise.

Small studies suggest that pink noise may help stabilize deep sleep and memory consolidation in some adults, while brown noise is more of a user driven trend, especially in ADHD and “busy brain” communities, with early evidence and lots of anecdotes rather than big trials.

If you are trying to choose, the most practical way is to run a two week at home test, keeping volume low and sleep times consistent, and see whether pink noise, brown noise, or no added noise gives you the calmest nights.

Pros

  • More personalized than “just get a sound machine”
    By thinking in terms of brown vs pink noise for sleep, you can choose a sound that matches your brain and your bedroom, instead of treating all noise as the same.

  • Grounded in both research and real life use
    Pink noise has experimental data around deep sleep and memory, brown noise has growing ADHD and busy brain anecdotes, and both are framed honestly as “may help”, not magic.

  • Easy to test at home
    You can run a two week experiment with free apps or a basic device, no need for lab gear or complicated setups.

  • Fits into a wider quiet bedroom strategy
    Brown and pink noise work best as part of a bigger picture, earplugs for peaks, sound for smoothing, a consistent routine, not as the only tool.

Cons

  • Evidence is still limited
    Most studies are small, timing controlled, and done in labs. We do not have huge trials showing one noise color is universally best for sleep.

  • Not everyone likes background sound
    Some people, especially those with sensory sensitivities, find any constant noise more annoying than helpful.

  • Can backfire if too loud
    Cranking volume to drown everything out can disturb sleep and, over years, potentially strain hearing, especially if the device is very close.

  • Easy to focus on the gadget instead of the basics
    Noise is one lever. Light, routine, caffeine, and stress still do most of the heavy lifting. It is tempting to keep tweaking sounds instead of tackling those.

Notes

  • If you have chronic insomnia, especially with daytime impact, CBT I remains the main evidence based treatment. Pink or brown noise are supporting actors, not the star of the show.

  • If you have tinnitus or ADHD, think in terms of “does this make my nights feel calmer overall”, not “does this cure the underlying condition”. If your symptoms are severe, loop in a clinician.

  • If your first impression of a noise color is “meh”, give it four to seven nights before deciding. Your brain needs a little time to learn that this new sound is safe, predictable, and ignorable.

Used this way, the brown vs pink noise question becomes less of an internet argument and more of a small, curious experiment, which is exactly the kind of mindset that tends to help with sleep in the long run.

Sources

  • Ngo HVV, et al. (2013) NeuronAuditory closed-loop stimulation of slow oscillations enhanced memory in sleeping adults. (This is timed, not continuous playback.) PubMed

  • Papalambros NA, et al. (2017) Frontiers in Human Neuroscience — Pink-noise acoustic stimulation increased slow-wave activity and memory in older adults. PMC

  • Schade MM, et al. (2020) — Open-loop pink noise amplified slow oscillatory/delta activity; methodology differs from everyday playback. PMC

  • Yoon H, et al. (2022) — Review on external auditory stimulation; most closed-loop work uses pink noise bursts. PMC

  • Riedy SM, et al. (2021) Sleep Medicine ReviewsSystematic review: very low-quality evidence that continuous broadband noise improves sleep; potential downsides if loud. PubMed

text